1621 New York Ave Cape May, NJ 08204

New owner since Apr 1, 2026Built 1999 · Residential · Tidelands claim1 owner signal on a paid plan
Assessed
$1,200,000
Last sale
$3,500,000Apr 1, 2026
Built
1999
Size
2,808 sq ft
Status
No open cases

Property information

Block
1187
Lot
11
Qualifier
—
County
Cape May
Municipality
Cape May City
Tax map page
56
Land description
75X125

Building details

Building class
19
Description
3S-F
Dwellings
1
Zoning
R1PW
Square feet
2,808
Acreage
0.22 ac

Assessment

Land value
$875,000
73%
Improvement value
$325,000
27%
Total assessment
$1,200,000
Sale assessment
Sign in to see
Tax (2024)
$12,684

Owner mailing

Street address

Property information on this site is compiled from public sources and is provided as-is; we do not guarantee its accuracy.

9 events · 1994–2026

Sign in to see the parties and documents

  • Deed recorded

    +192% vs 2010
    $3,500,000
    Held2.4 yrsRecordedApr 7, 2026
  • Notice of settlement recorded

    Instrument2026091193CountyCape_may
  • 16 years
  • Deed recorded

    +860% vs 1996
    $1,200,000
    Held7.6 yrs
  • 11 years
  • Property Built

  • Deed recorded

    -89% vs 1996
    $125,000
    Held0 mo
  • Deed recorded

    $1,100,000
    Held2.5 yrs

YearProperty taxChangeLandImprovementAssessment
2024$12,684-1.6%$875,000$325,000$1,200,000
2023$12,888+5.5%$875,000$325,000$1,200,000
2022$12,216+4.9%$875,000$325,000$1,200,000
2021$11,640-1.7%$875,000$325,000$1,200,000
2020$11,844+6.0%$875,000$325,000$1,200,000
2019$11,172+5.3%$875,000$325,000$1,200,000
2018$10,608+6.3%$875,000$325,000$1,200,000
2017$9,984-3.8%$875,000$325,000$1,200,000
2016$10,3800.0%$875,000$325,000$1,200,000
2015$10,380+3.2%$875,000$325,000$1,200,000
2014$10,056+1.3%$875,000$325,000$1,200,000
2013$9,924+5.5%$875,000$325,000$1,200,000
2012$9,408-9.8%$875,000$325,000$1,200,000
2011$10,433+6.3%$875,000$325,000$1,200,000
2010$9,813+2.4%$875,000$534,800$1,409,800
2009$9,583+8.2%$612,500$537,900$1,150,400
2008$8,858+0.0%$612,500$537,900$1,150,400
2007$8,858+3.6%$612,500$537,900$1,150,400
2006$8,5480.0%$612,500$537,900$1,150,400
2005$8,548-7.3%$612,500$512,300$1,124,800
2004$9,222+3.4%$612,500$512,300$1,124,800
2003$8,921+9.9%$175,500$325,700$501,200
2002$8,119-4.1%$175,500$325,700$501,200
2001$8,470+3.7%$175,500$325,700$501,200
2000$8,170+190.9%$175,500$325,700$501,200
1999$2,808+17.0%$175,500—$175,500
1998$2,399+1.9%$175,500—$175,500
1997$2,355+0.6%$146,300—$146,300
1996$2,341+2.6%$146,300—$146,300
1995$2,282+6.1%$146,300—$146,300
1994$2,151+65.0%$146,300—$146,300
1992$1,303+8.4%$72,000—$72,000
1991$1,202+702.5%$72,000—$72,000
1990$150—$72,000—$72,000