NJPropData
HomeDashboard

Data Explorer

DataWorkspaceBetaReportsPDFDocs

5416 Bay Ave Ocean City, NJ 08226

Built 1967Residential
Get report
Street ViewSign in to view
Street ViewSatellite view
Map of this property's location
Open on map
Assessed
$459,800
Last sale
$999,000Apr 25, 2025
Built
1967
Size
1,496 sq ft
Owner
Sign in to see
Status
No open cases

Property information

Block
5407
Lot
5
Qualifier
—
County
Cape May
Municipality
Ocean City
Tax map page
33A
Land description
50X95

Building details

Building class
45
Description
1S-F
Dwellings
2
Zoning
—
Square feet
1,496
Acreage
0.11 ac

Assessment

Land value
$323,400
70%
Improvement value
$136,400
30%
Total assessment
$459,800
Sale assessment
Sign in to see
Tax (2024)
$5,159

Owner mailing

Street address
Sign in to see

Property information on this site is compiled from public sources and is provided as-is; we do not guarantee its accuracy.

  1. Home
  2. /
  3. NJ Property Records
  4. /
  5. Cape May County
  6. /
  7. Ocean City
  8. /
  9. Block 5407
  10. /
  11. 5416 Bay Ave, Ocean City, NJ 08226

9 events · 1967–2025
Sales5Notices of settlement3
  • 2025Apr 25

    Deed recorded

    +2% vs 2023
    $999,000
    Held1.5 yrs

    Sign in to see the details

  • 2025Mar 27

    Notice of settlement recorded

    Instrument2025061831CountyCape_may

    Sign in to see the details

  • 2023Oct 24

    Deed recorded

    +103% vs 2018
    $983,000
    Held5.8 yrsRecordedOct 27, 2023

    Sign in to see the details

  • 2023Oct 19

    Notice of settlement recorded

    Instrument2023023129CountyCape_may

    Sign in to see the details

  • 6 years
  • 2018Jan 19

    Deed recorded

    +273% vs 1995
    $485,000
    Held22.4 yrsRecordedFeb 13, 2018

    Sign in to see the details

  • 2017Dec 15

    Notice of settlement recorded

    Instrument2017039085CountyCape_may

    Sign in to see the details

  • 22 years
  • 1995Sep 9

    Deed recorded

    -10% vs 1987
    $130,000
    Held8.2 yrs

    Sign in to see the details

  • 8 years
  • 1987Jun 27

    Deed recorded

    $144,500

    Sign in to see the details

  • 20 years
  • 1967

    Property Built

35 years · 1989–2024
YearProperty taxChangeLandImprovementAssessment
2024$5,159+11.2%$323,400$136,400$459,800
2023$4,637+6.6%$323,400$136,400$459,800
2022$4,352+2.8%$323,400$109,600$433,000
2021$4,235+1.1%$323,400$109,600$433,000
2020$4,187+0.9%$323,400$109,600$433,000
2019$4,148+1.6%$323,400$109,600$433,000
2018$4,083+4.0%$323,400$109,600$433,000
2017$3,927+1.3%$323,400$109,600$433,000

5320 Simpson Ave, Ocean City, NJ 08226Residential1,484 sq ftAssessed $548,0000.10 mi away-1% sq ftView details5229 Bay Ave, Ocean City, NJ 08226Residential1,516 sq ftAssessed $596,4000.17 mi away+1% sq ftView details232 Dory Dr, Ocean City, NJ 08226Residential1,512 sq ftAssessed $470,9000.18 mi away+1% sq ftView details5408 Bay Ave, Ocean City, NJ 08226Residential1,600 sq ftAssessed $420,5000.02 mi away+7% sq ftView details5622 Central Ave, Ocean City, NJ 08226Residential1,409 sq ftAssessed $532,9000.36 mi away-6% sq ftView details

Sign in to see sale prices and dates

Sign in to keep notes

Your notes stay private to you.

Sign in

  • 5400 Bay Ave, Ocean City, NJ 08226Lot 1
  • 5404 Bay Ave, Ocean City, NJ 08226Lot 2
  • 5408 Bay Ave, Ocean City, NJ 08226Lot 3
  • 5412 Bay Ave, Ocean City, NJ 08226Lot 4
  • 5420 Bay Ave, Ocean City, NJ 08226Lot 6
  • 5424 Bay Ave, Ocean City, NJ 08226Lot 7
  • 5428 Bay Ave, Ocean City, NJ 08226Lot 8
  • 5432 Bay Ave, Ocean City, NJ 08226Lot 9
  • 5436-38 Bay Ave, Ocean City, NJ 08226Lot 10 (C1)
  • 5436-38 Bay Ave, Ocean City, NJ 08226Lot 10 (C2)
  • 237 Anchorage Dr, Ocean City, NJ 08226Lot 11
  • 233 Anchorage Dr, Ocean City, NJ 08226Lot 12
All 21 lots on Block 5407