NJPropData
HomeDashboard

Data Explorer

DataWorkspaceBetaReportsDocs

76 Carey Ave Butler, NJ 07405

Built 1930Residential
Get report
Street ViewSign in to view
Street ViewSatellite view
Map of this property's location
Open on map
Assessed
$612,900
Last sale
$795,000Apr 17, 2026
Built
1930
Size
2,382 sq ft
Owner
Sign in to see
Status
No open cases

Property information

Block
7
Lot
20
Qualifier
—
County
Morris
Municipality
Butler Boro
Tax map page
8
Land description
72X225

Building details

Building class
18
Description
2S-AL-L-DG-1U
Dwellings
1
Zoning
R-5
Square feet
2,382
Acreage
0.37 ac

Assessment

Land value
$316,300
52%
Improvement value
$296,600
48%
Total assessment
$612,900
Sale assessment
Sign in to see
Tax (2024)
$12,880

Owner mailing

Street address
Sign in to see

Property information on this site is compiled from public sources and is provided as-is; we do not guarantee its accuracy.

  1. Home
  2. /
  3. NJ Property Records
  4. /
  5. Morris County
  6. /
  7. Butler Boro
  8. /
  9. Block 7
  10. /
  11. 76 Carey Ave, Butler, NJ 07405

2 events · 1930–2026
Sales1
  • 2026Apr 17

    Deed recorded

    $795,000
    Per sq ft$334Sq ft2,382RecordedApr 29, 2026

    Sign in to see the details

  • 96 years
  • 1930

    Property Built

County clerks also index recorded documents by address and by the names on them. Search Morris County records

36 years · 1989–2024
YearProperty taxChangeLandImprovementAssessment
2024$12,880+2.7%$316,300$296,600$612,900
2023$12,538-5.7%$253,800$262,000$515,800
2022$13,289+2.6%$190,000$232,900$422,900
2021$12,949+2.2%$164,000$182,600$346,600
2020$12,665+1.3%$164,000$182,600$346,600
2019$12,502+2.6%$164,000$182,600$346,600
2018$12,183+2.7%$164,000$182,600$346,600
2017$11,868+1.6%$164,000$182,600$346,600

49 Central Ave, Butler, NJ 07405Residential2,390 sq ftAssessed $350,8000.05 mi awaysame sizeView details14 George St, Butler, NJ 07405Residential2,388 sq ftAssessed $467,0000.07 mi awaysame sizeView details6 Third St, Butler, NJ 07405Residential2,374 sq ftAssessed $605,3000.49 mi awaysame sizeView details117 Bartholdi Ave, Butler, NJ 07405Residential2,406 sq ftAssessed $640,7000.60 mi away+1% sq ftView details55 Kiel Ave, Butler, NJ 07405Residential2,408 sq ftAssessed $547,4000.60 mi away+1% sq ftView details

Sign in to see sale prices and dates

Sign in to keep notes

Your notes stay private to you.

Sign in

  • 72 Carey Ave, Butler, NJ 07405Lot 1
  • 24 George St, Butler, NJ 07405Lot 2.01
  • 26 George St, Butler, NJ 07405Lot 2
  • 22 George St, Butler, NJ 07405Lot 3
  • 20 George St, Butler, NJ 07405Lot 4
  • 18 George St, Butler, NJ 07405Lot 5
  • 16 George St, Butler, NJ 07405Lot 6
  • 14 George St, Butler, NJ 07405Lot 7
  • 12 George St, Butler, NJ 07405Lot 8
  • 10 George St, Butler, NJ 07405Lot 9
  • 8 George St, Butler, NJ 07405Lot 10
  • 81 High St, Butler, NJ 07405Lot 11
All 33 lots on Block 7