NJPropData
HomeDashboard

Data Explorer

DataWorkspaceBetaReportsPDFDocs

4 Mahlon Casterlin Ave Newton, NJ 07860

Built 1940Residential
Get report
Street ViewSign in to view
Street ViewSatellite view
Map of this property's location
Open on map
Assessed
$155,800
Last sale
$1Nov 7, 2025
Built
1940
Size
895 sq ft
Owner
Sign in to see
Status
No open cases

Property information

Block
255
Lot
11
Qualifier
—
County
Sussex
Municipality
Frankford Twp
Tax map page
1503
Land description
.505 ACSR

Building details

Building class
15
Description
1SF
Dwellings
1
Zoning
AR
Square feet
895
Acreage
0.51 ac

Assessment

Land value
$76,600
49%
Improvement value
$79,200
51%
Total assessment
$155,800
Sale assessment
Sign in to see
Tax (2024)
$4,633

Owner mailing

Street address
Sign in to see

Property information on this site is compiled from public sources and is provided as-is; we do not guarantee its accuracy.

  1. Home
  2. /
  3. NJ Property Records
  4. /
  5. Sussex County
  6. /
  7. Frankford Twp
  8. /
  9. Block 255
  10. /
  11. 4 Mahlon Casterlin Ave, Newton, NJ 07860

2 events · 1940–2025
  • 1940

    Property Built

County clerks also index recorded documents by address and by the names on them. Search Sussex County records

36 years · 1989–2024
YearProperty taxChangeLandImprovementAssessment
2024$4,633+3.1%$76,600$79,200$155,800
2023$4,495+5.7%$76,600$79,200$155,800
2022$4,253+2.9%$76,600$79,200$155,800
2021$4,132+2.9%$76,600$79,200$155,800
2020$4,015+0.9%$76,600$79,200$155,800
2019$3,978+0.4%$76,600$79,200$155,800
2018$3,964-1.2%$76,600$79,200$155,800
2017$4,013+0.5%$76,600$79,200$155,800

444 Us Highway 206, Branchville, NJ 07826Residential900 sq ftAssessed $100,5001.13 mi away+1% sq ftView details29 Cottage Ave, Newton, NJ 07860Residential895 sq ftAssessed $201,7000.31 mi awaysame sizeView details64 Blackford Rd, Newton, NJ 07860Residential929 sq ftAssessed $454,0001.17 mi away+4% sq ftView details183 E Shore Lk Owassa Rd, Newton, NJ 07860Residential962 sq ftAssessed $203,5000.46 mi away+7% sq ftView details38 Blackford Rd, Newton, NJ 07860Residential842 sq ftAssessed $216,4001.08 mi away-6% sq ftView details

Sign in to see sale prices and dates

Sign in to keep notes

Your notes stay private to you.

Sign in

  • 17 Howell Ave, Newton, NJ 07860Lot 1
  • 13 Howell Ave, Newton, NJ 07860Lot 3
  • 11 Howell Ave, Newton, NJ 07860Lot 4
  • 3 Howell Ave, Newton, NJ 07860Lot 6
  • 92 E Shore Lk Owassa Rd, Newton, NJ 07860Lot 7
  • 94 E Shore Lk Owassa Rd, Newton, NJ 07860Lot 8
  • 96 E Shore Lk Owassa Rd, Newton, NJ 07860Lot 9
  • 2 Mahlon Casterlin Ave, Newton, NJ 07860Lot 10
  • 6 Mahlon Casterlin Ave, Newton, NJ 07860Lot 12
  • 10 Mahlon Casterlin Ave, Newton, NJ 07860Lot 13
All 11 lots on Block 255